Timing the first human migration into eastern asia. Pdf the dispersal of homo sapiens out of africa is a significant topic in human evolutionary studies. Jul 19, 2019 the out of africa ooa, or african replacement, hypothesis is a wellsupported theory. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development quamrul ashraf, oded galor 01 august 2011 this column goes back even further to the cradle of humankind in east africa, suggesting that the genetic diversity of the tribes that dispersed to different parts of the globe determined their success many. Theres been some recent articles which have been interpreted as stating that the out of africa hypothesis has been debunked, in this video i hope to address that. It advances and empirically establishes the hypothesis that, in the course of the exodus of homo sapiens out of africa, variation in migratory distance from the cradle of humankind to various settlements across the globe affected genetic diversity, and has had a longlasting effect on the pattern of comparative economic development that is not. Outline atkinson paper phonemic inventories and linguistic diffusion hypothesis wals data fitting atkinsons cline model spatial and variancecomponent models controversies. These important findings put a proverbial dent in the out of africa theory. Set apart, it is not a strong argument because a mix of different dna lineages also results in a high variability and, as we show below, it is largely what occurs in africa. Pdf out of africa and the evolution of human behavior. Rozhanski only confirms the denial of any african ancestry in nonafricans, and strongly supports the existence of a common. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic.
This paper can be downloaded without charge from the. Out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, an american. It advances and empirically establishes the hypothesis that, in the course of the exodus of homo sapiens out of africa, variation in migratory distance from the cradle of humankind to various settlements across the globe affected genetic diversity and has had a longlasting effect on the pattern of comparative economic development that is not. In each great region of the world the living mammals are closely related. But were having to reevaluate the outofafrica model now because genetic data suggest that the modern humans who came out of africa about 60,000 years ago probably interbred with neanderthals, first of all, and then some of them later on interbred with another group of people called the denisovans, over in south eastern asia. Biology primate evolution and find homework help for other science questions at. Scientific consensus favours this theory over the multiregional theory, however, it is still debated whether there was a single exodus out of africa or several. On the other hand, forced integration may exacerbate divisions and lead to the opposite outcome e. Pdf evaluation of out of africa hypotheses by means of.
The bohunician and the szeletian both root in the local. The first was the unilinear, or neanderthal phase, hypothesis of. Following a series of astonishing scientific discoveries during the last five years, the out of africa theory is under intense pressure it could be argued that it has already collapsed under the weight of contradictory evidence. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development by quamrul ashraf and oded galor online appendix this appendix i discusses empirical results from additional robustness checks conducted for the historical analysis section a, ii presents the methodology underlying. Jul 26, 2014 a very recent paper on ychromosomes published in 2012, reexaming the out of africa theory and the origin of europeoids caucasians in the light of dna genealogy written by anatole a. It is instructive to examine the way in which the out of africa model has.
Apr 21, 2016 the replacement, or out of africa ooa, model proposes a single and relatively recent transition from archaic hominins to amh in africa, followed by a later migration to the rest of the world, replacing other extant hominin populations. The outofafrica model is also known as the recent singleorigin hypothesis, and recent african origin theory. This research argues that deeprooted factors, determined tens of thousands of years ago, had a signi. It argues that every living human being is descended from a small group of homo sapiens abbreviated hss individuals in africa, who then dispersed into the wider world, meeting and displacing earlier forms such as neanderthals and denisovans. Under the out of africa hypothesis, the first humans to leave africa 1. Describe how the following lines of evidence support the out of africa hypothesis. It advances and empirically establishes the hypothesis that in the course of the exodus of homo sapiens out of africa, variation in migratory distance from the cradle of. The oldest homo sapiens fossils are found in africa around 195,000 years ago. Tabulate five differences between humans and other primates. Media in category out of africa the following 35 files are in this category, out of 35 total. Out of africa theory called into question by originator.
Interpretation of a phylogenetic tree to show the place of the family hominidae in the animal kingdom characteristics that we share with other primates. The original out of africa hypothesis of modern human origins and subsequent pattern of global migration was based on mitochondrial dna mtdna evidence, which revealed a series of population bottlenecks and a progressive loss of diversity moving away from east africa. The out of africa 2 hypothesis for the origin of anatomically modern humans posits the replacement of the original populations of homo with a second dispersal hence 2 of near modern humans from africa, a dispersal that purportedly replaced the archaic east asian and neanderthal populations without gene exchange. Main hypothesis the migration of humans out of africa 60,00090,000 bp a. Contrast the multiregional hypothesis and the out of. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development, department of economics working papers 2010, department of economics, williams college, revised dec 2012. Evaluation of out of africa hypotheses by means of agentbased modeling article pdf available in quaternary international december 2015 with 415 reads how we measure reads. Prevailing hypotheses of comparative economic development highlight various. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity. The out of africa hypothesis of comparative economic. To gain a possibly objective measure of racial prejudice, we administered a series of implicit. This research advances and empirically establishes the hypothesis that. The out of africa hypothesis is an evolutionary theory of modern human origin that posits that modern humans arose in the late pleistocene, about 100,000200,000 years ago, in africa. The out of africa, or african replacement hypothesis, states that every living human is descended from a group in africa who spread across the world replacing earlier neanderthals.
What are some scientific arguments against the oat out of. Get an answer for contrast the multiregional hypothesis and the out of africa hypothesis for human evolution. A critique of the out of africa model michael maystadt illinois state university in the scientific community, there is a general consensus as to the origin and history of modern humans. Has the out of africa theory been debunked as of 2017. The late middle paleolithic and earliest upper paleolithic in. Human evolution 17 april 20 lesson description in this lesson, we. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development by quamrul ashraf and oded. Predictions the tests of the out of africa hypothesis conducted by hawks et al. The multiregional hypothesis and the out of africa 2 model are two. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development this research argues that deeprooted factors, determined tens of thousands of years ago, had a significant effect on the course of economic development from the dawn of human civilization to the contemporary era. The archaeological recordin eastern and southeastern central europe in eastern central europe, especially in moravia, there are two main transitional industries. Fossil record by referring to fossil sites in the rift valley in east africa kenya and tanzania, ethiopia and south africa mitochondrial dna. Recent african origin, or out of africa ii, refers to the migration of anatomically modern humans homo sapiens out of africa after their emergence at c. Sep 08, 2009 so then, a strict out of africa hypothesis posits that homo sapiens evolved from an african population of homo heidelbergensis about 200,000 years ago, and subsequently dispersed across the globe, wiping out or outcompeting any archaic human populations they came across without interbreeding with them.
The 22 marker haplotypes, which are the slowest in terms. Reexamining the out of africa theory and the origin of. The out of africa hypothesis of comparative economic development. Multiregional one of the biggest debates today in paleoanthropology concerns the origins of modern humans. A critique of the out of africa model michael maystadt. The out of africa hypothesis is a wellsupported theory that argues that every living human being is descended from a small group in africa, who then dispersed into the wider world displacing earlier forms such as neanderthal. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and. Omokibish i omo i from southern ethiopia is the oldest. It advances and empirically establishes the hypothesis that, in the course of the exodus of homo sapiens out of africa, variation in migratory distance from the. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development by quamrul ashraf and oded galor. It seems that it is now fashionable to say humans interbred with a variety of other neanderthaltype species and this idea about becoming modern in africa before spreading across the globe is oldfashioned for the 1990s pc crowd. The out of africa ooa, or african replacement, hypothesis is a wellsupported theory. Before humans evolved into modern form, homo sapiens populated africa and the middle east, homo erectus lived in asia, and neandertals populated europe.
The widelyheldconfirmed in 2007theory that ancestors of modern humans can be traced to a single population that lived in africa about 200,000 years ago. Contrast the multiregional hypothesis and the out of africa. The following 35 files are in this category, out of 35 total. Modern homo sapiens can trace their origin back to homo erectus interbreeding between early hominin species in europe and asia lead to the distinctive features of modern homo sapiens modern homo sapiens and neanderthals have no common ancestor more recent than the first mammals. This influential literature has attracted the attention of some scholars from other disciplines, and in light of existing methodological gaps across fields, has perhaps unsurprisingly. Jun 05, 2017 theres been some recent articles which have been interpreted as stating that the out of africa hypothesis has been debunked, in this video i hope to address that. On the reliability of recent tests of the out of africa. Jan 08, 2020 in this field the pace of scientific research, discovery and reinterpretation has in recent years been so rapid that what constitutes current scientific opinion is something of a moving target with impassioned debate on each side. Early major proponents of this theory were led by british. There are a number of different sources of evidence being thrown around these days that refute the out of africa hypothesis.
The outof africa hypothesis peter mccullagh department of statistics university of chicago south africa, november 20. Ashraf, oded galor, and marc klemp abstract the importance of the prehistoric migration of anatomically modern humans from africa for comparative economic development has been the focus of a vibrant. The importance of the prehistoric migration of anatomically modern humans from africa for comparative economic development has been the focus of a vibrant research agenda in the past decade. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development by quamrul ashraf and oded galor this research advances and empirically establishes the hypothesis that, in the course of the prehistoric exodus of homo sapiens out of africa, variation in migratory distance to various settlements across. The late middle paleolithic and earliest upper paleolithic.
Out of africa 2 also called the population replacement hypothesis picks up where out of africa 1 leaves off. Out of africa by the time the most advanced species of modern man, homo sapiens, had evolved, about 120,000 years ago, there is evidence of rapid population growth around the globe. Which of the following is consistent with the outofafrica hypothesis. Explain the out of africa hypothesis using evidence from various sources to support it. Species, of course, are defined by reproductive isolation, so the evolution of these several species of humans was separate. Machinereadable bibliographic record marc, ris, bibtex document object identifier doi. A very recent paper on ychromosomes published in 2012, reexaming the out of africa theory and the origin of europeoids caucasians in the light of dna genealogy written by anatole a. Common misconceptions, working papers 2018, brown university, department of economics. The debate thus becomes one between the strict out of africa, which claims our species expanded out from africa without interbreeding with the archaic humans they found the replacement model, and a revised multiregional hypothesis which claims interbreeding did in fact take place and helps account for regional differences between. Levant seems a quite appropriate place to test the out of. Out of africa 1 contends that earlier homo species did in fact migrate from africa before the evolution of h. Which of the following is consistent with the out of africa hypothesis. There are different versions of out of africa, but its major tenet is that modern humans originated as a discrete population or species that rapidly.
The out of africa model is also known as the recent singleorigin hypothesis, and recent african origin theory. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development. The out of africa hypothesis of comparative development re ected by nighttime light intensity quamrul ashraf oded galor marc klemp april 26, 2014 abstract this research establishes that migratory distance from the cradle of anatomically modern humans in east africa and its e ect on the distribution of genetic. Study 7 terms biology 151 final flashcards quizlet. This research advances and empirically establishes the hypothesis that, in the course of the prehistoric exodus of homo sapiens out of africa. Jul 21, 2017 following a series of astonishing scientific discoveries during the last five years, the out of africa theory is under intense pressure it could be argued that it has already collapsed under the weight of contradictory evidence. The out of africa hypothesis of comparative development. The replacement, or out of africa ooa, model proposes a single and relatively recent transition from archaic hominins to amh in africa, followed by a later migration to the rest of the world, replacing other extant hominin populations. State that the out of africa hypothesis states that all modern humans originated in africa. Bootstrap standard errors, accounting for the use of generated regressors, are reported in parentheses. The out of africa hypothesis, human genetic diversity, and comparative economic development this research argues that deeprooted factors, determined tens of thousands of years ago, had a significant effect on the course of economic development from the.
1093 880 136 252 1482 638 1473 1251 467 396 794 1232 448 1175 1056 762 96 1302 1219 225 1230 1396 1238 613 1079 438 297 977 224 337 337 770 1487 347 944 1112 1021 1427 694 1198 1118 831 376 1454 170